Case LawSupreme Court › [1989] 2 S.C.R. 302

Alembic Chemical Works Co. Ltd v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Gujarat

Supreme Court [1989] 2 S.C.R. 302 31 Mar 1989 In favour of: Assessee
Forum / Bench
Supreme Court
Parties
Alembic Chemical Works Co. Ltd v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Gujarat
Date of order
31 Mar 1989
Assessment year(s)
Outcome
Allowed

Case analysis

⚙️ Auto-generated structured summary from the order — a quick research aid, not a hand-reviewed analysis. Read the original judgment below for authority.
In Alembic Chemical Works Co. Ltd v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Gujarat, the Supreme Court (1989) allowed the appeal. The decision went in favour of the assessee.
Legal topics
Transfer pricing

Original judgment (source document)

The analysis above is EaseValue's editorial summary. Below is the court's original order, reproduced from the public record as a source document — the OCR text is cleaned for readability but may retain scanning artifacts; rely on the official source for the authentic version.
▸ Show the full original order (source text)
[1990] 2 Bao fao qo 38400 |Unitas afar aaa aot fafaze TATA ATART AAT, THT 31 ard, 1989| Yo Flo ATLo VHo WSs Al Alo UMo Uo AHeAAT aranet afafaam, 1961 (1961 st 43)—arer 37—zIHeaeQT ATGait cag sautiza wea H fag atlerr—vat ats ca afan wealet agt ge at Fa ate at caerey at fe aat gs faface afead qatar waea— ate at caerey at fe aat gs faface afead qatar waea— at caerey at fe aat gs faface afead qatar waea— caerey at fe aat gs faface afead qatar waea— at fe aat gs faface afead qatar waea— fe aat gs faface afead qatar waea— aat gs faface afead qatar waea— gs faface afead qatar waea— faface afead qatar waea— afead qatar waea— qatar waea— waea—ag fatez aeat aitz afefeafaat rx fate azat g—afafaar ar fafaator azaret va waat stat Gafafert wr seats agitfaa agatat cage ata aleae ara HARTY et BLAH fre op fase sae R arr HUT— HTTwert ‘aar & fae’ afar cfs et aata-— ar aaa Tea cay A ae Taefar aetat waar Zt7 equa Fa ate at caerey at fe aat gs faface afead qatar waea— ate at caerey at fe aat gs faface afead qatar waea— at caerey at fe aat gs faface afead qatar waea— caerey at fe aat gs faface afead qatar waea— at fe aat gs faface afead qatar waea— fe aat gs faface afead qatar waea— aat gs faface afead qatar waea— gs faface afead qatar waea— faface afead qatar waea— afead qatar waea— qatar waea— waea— — aaet afafaaa, 1961 (1961 wt 43)-- amet 37—‘aar & far’ atx ‘faregrat wae’ & faa cua & avian aat fara agl gli— aa s yew,sataat ale cata wt Fe Hr A fafaraa feat arat gat z| sfastfan ate ateg-araa garat & fafaato F aaa fraifed) aot ataaa aaa & gfaera sfasfan tafafaa at fatrain at at aqafta dt 7gay| axraq gan & artan ant a fratfeat at aad eter sain F are aw Aafa-fat gerren qaat & Faeargel-adt seared sift at aat ataq 1963 Fqafafrar wr scares aera H VeeT a fratfedt + un facet aad B, at shastagarat & fafaate 4 <a faeaa van %, araata Ht ate ag fratfedt at artfiraaHATHT STATE ATT AA FH fra aga Mt Te fraa fa fratfedl Tease stevia,PRodtacr at Fgax sfaar at ga faaeit watt arefanfaa agax AafafaaBeales Aaa! Hl ATA AIA vet sacHa slat H us faefifaer a tafafaa F10,000 & afar afrel aT scared HUH IA BaaHF LAL Bl away BT A ah| at aaa F ofeTAtaST Hux fear Tar faas aeltes fasat saat50,000 andar staz (Haid 2,39,625 sac) & ‘gat & fae’ sfanacaeqaaa faatfedt at sa fate aot & aalfas sega aafefar faatfedt at sa fate aot & aalfas sega aafefar at sa fate aot & aalfas sega aafefar sa fate aot & aalfas sega aafefar fate aot & aalfas sega aafefar aot & aalfas sega aafefar & aalfas sega aafefar aalfas sega aafefar sega aafefar aafefar sareeaaa F sasitarmpat, Tafafaa F fHodtncn Hy sa fadet sodt sy shear: atanal aATHTA, erage ara ate fafad faaxyagar saifia aaa F ar aaarat oPear ar cag ae ate ta salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa oPear ar cag ae ate ta salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa ar cag ae ate ta salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa cag ae ate ta salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa ae ate ta salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa ate ta salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa ta salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa aaa Fs yea vacant } festa Fs yea vacant } festa yea vacant } festa vacant } festa } festa festa ate_fafadait ar sar we, ga fateh aad & aaa He frathed B aadtat sf ast ah tara aaa faatfedt at sa fate aot & aalfas sega aafefar faatfedt at sa fate aot & aalfas sega aafefar at sa fate aot & aalfas sega aafefar sa fate aot & aalfas sega aafefar fate aot & aalfas sega aafefar aot & aalfas sega aafefar & aalfas sega aafefar aalfas sega aafefar sega aafefar aafefar saree arat oPear ar cag ae ate ta salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa oPear ar cag ae ate ta salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa ar cag ae ate ta salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa cag ae ate ta salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa ae ate ta salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa ate ta salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa ta salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa salts aaa Fs yea vacant } festa aaa Fs yea vacant } festa Fs yea vacant } festa yea vacant } festa vacant } festa } festa festa ate
Facing a similar income-tax issue?
Our CA-led litigation team handles notices, scrutiny, penalties and appeals (CIT(A) & ITAT) end-to-end.
✅ Get help with an income-tax notice → 💬 Ask our CA
This page reproduces a public-domain court order (Section 52(1)(q)(iv), Copyright Act 1957). Explanations are EaseValue's original analysis. Always read the original order.
Disclaimer: General information only — not legal, tax or professional advice, and no advocate/CA–client relationship is created. AI-generated summaries may contain errors and must be verified against the original court order. EaseValue accepts no liability for reliance on this content. Not a solicitation. Full disclaimer & Terms.
Contact Careers Media / Press · Privacy Terms Refund Cancellation Cookies Disclaimer
© 2026 EaseValue Advisors LLP · LLPIN ACN-4920 · Jaipur, Rajasthan