Broach Distt. Co-Operative Cotton Sales Ginning & Pressing Society Ltd v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Ahmedabad

BROACH DISTI. CO-OPERATIVE COTION SALES GINNING & PRESSING SOCIETY L'IJ). v. COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX, AHMEDABAD. APRIL 26, 1989 [R.S. PATHAK CJ. AND M.H. KANIA, J.) Income Tax Act, 1961: Section 81(i)(c)-Assessee-Co-opera-tive Society-Income from ginning and pressing-Whether exempt from tax. The assessee, a co-operative _society, was rendering the service of ginning and pressing raw cotton received from its members and marketing the finished product on their behalf. The assessee charged the members a certain amount6y way of ginning and pressing charges ana further charged commission for the sale of the finished product. For the assessment years 1961-62 to 1963-64, the assessee claimed that the receipts from the ginning and pressing activities were exempt under section 81(i)(c) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (as it stood then) which provided that income-tax shall not be payable by a co-operative society in respect of the profits and gains of business carried on by it, if it was a society engaged in the marketing of the agricultural produce of its members. The Income Tax Officer declined to accept the claim on the ground that the assessee had been carrying out the process of ginning and pressing with the aid of power. The Appellate Assistant Commis-sioner confirmed the orders of the Income Tax OffiCilr. The Appellate F Tribunal allowed the second appeal of the assessee holding that the ginning and pressing activities were to be regarded as an integral part of the marketing activity. The High Court, while deciding the reference in favour of the Revenue, observed that the assessee carried on ginning and pressing of cotton with the aid of power, and even if those activities were regarded as ancillary or incident.ii to its market!ng:actjvIT1;·they G would not' come Within the category of exempted activities in view of the proviso to the section. Allowing the appeals, this Court, H HELD: (1) Ginning and pressing was part of the integral process of marketing. It was an activity incidental or ancillary to marketing, which included the ginning and pressing of raw cotton and was not A confined to selling activity alone. The members did not take back the cotton after it was ginned and pressed. All the raw cotton so treated was marketed by the assessee on behalf of its members to the outside world and not to its members. [723G-H; 724A] Addi. Commissioner of Income-Tax, Karnataka v. Ryots B Agricultural Produce Co-operative Society Ltd., [1978] 115 ITR 709; Commissioner of Income-Tax, Gujarat IV v. Karjan Co-op. Cotton Sale, Ginning & Pressing Society Ltd., [1981] 129 ITR 821, referred to. (2) The object of s. 8l(i) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 was to encourage and promote the growth of co-operative societies, and conse-quently a liberal construction must be given to the operation of that C provision. [724A-B] (3) The proviso to s. 81(i)operates to exclude from the exemption those activities which can be regarded as separate and distinct from the activities enumerated in cla~es (a) to (I) of s. 8l(i). If the activity in D question is incidental or ancillary to one of the activities mentioned in those clauses, the proviso will not apply. [724B] (4) The assessee is entitled to the exemption of the profits and gains derived from the activity of the entire business of ginning and pressing of cotton and marketing it by virtue of cl. (c) of s. 81(i) of the Income-tax Act, and the High Court erred in holding to the contrary. [724F-GI CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal Nos. 513-515 (NT) of 1975. From the Judgment and Order dated 24.9.1973 of the Gujarat F High Court in Income Tax Reference· No. 31of1971. T.A. Ramachandran, Mrs. A.K. Verma and D.N. Mishra for the· Appellant. C.M. Lodha, K.C. Dua and Ms. A. Subhashini for the Res-G pondent. lbe Judgment of the Court was delivered by PATHAK, <;J. These appeals by certificate_ granted _by th,e. High Court of Gujarat are directed against the judgment of the Hi_gh Court vet fefezze ato ger Qea Fo HimHT aaea, agNaTaTZ ale & faut aga feat ate gue frat frerearet at fasey taraaita. setadar t aa ofefeataalait trae at ga seit araan stat fafeaa F 1 ae| saat6. aafa gracataa sit aac He, a TIA ena ag ar ator ae gfafeaa Hl fe ex wet aren sy F gana faeqa wz Es aatert fe aaa seafaart F eqogs 136 F ata at ae feat acta F tar wea al ate faaTEIT BY TT THT S| 7. afeoraa: adie cane at sax aa afer afta at arat Z t :cater afer at af 1 [1990] 3 BH0 fto qo 331 asta fefezae stanatiza Heaaca fnfan Gs Afat Marat feo|aaaCT~ WT-BL AAI, ACASTATS 26 att, 1989 Yo Wlo AITo THo AWSH WT Alo THo Gao wHfqay aa-wz afafaay, 1961—enzt 81(i)(7)---ageret afafeat et ara—afe ate agerel afafe aay aceat Behe gers F ates, WA at faqs atsae wagine at agian afafafizatF ait ge Bat ser, 8a site faqora ¥Sgr arzare at afafefeat & sea ara ate afeara a-ezt afafiaag & aeitaBe wet AT. —ertter feaaa—sare aalqaa—atiart saa—agert afafaatwt Seatfze wea F fae ara-ae afafaan % saat wr vere aulaaa fearwarat atfec|' faatfedt aantd afafa afafaan & area afea cm aaard afafa & 1afafa & geea ga ara B fay avatar & fe ga eg at Azar arfay atx. gaattial at cafses aaegt cat wea somaatal & far ce ara afer, aay aaeat&ale feat wea erage afe scare art F a1 freAuart saat aifec asai arfaatfefoat sat pea & atferora ger ate aera, ate ater ar fateHalal f AT Ga Aaeal F AAMHATA HT WAL HAT J I ag aaeatl a sara 332 ogra Hat & alt HaTa Hl Sas aaeat al ale a Jaa F faa ear ate axar @ lata al faa & ga ated ale Fas al Aare Hear H fae faatfedt sea atxqa F TANT H VT A ae & Ho HA asag afwHa sores Aaa Fh aafteren ot Bar Bt frateor ad 1961-62 & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF ot Bar Bt frateor ad 1961-62 & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF Bar Bt frateor ad 1961-62 & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF Bt frateor ad 1961-62 & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF frateor ad 1961-62 & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF ad 1961-62 & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF 1961-62 & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF 1963-64 % faaten B aaF % faaten B aaF faaten B aaF B aaF aaFFfaatfeat 4 ga ara at arar fear g fe Tea ate Mea aT HTaarfeal & siftaataa-at afafaaa st arer 81(i) (7)(wat fe ag sa aaa at) % ater wesea att aarfa, ata-ne aferara Fee areas ge ara BY eataTE BTA A AATax fearfe fratfedt fasrett at agiaar & sited atta at sfeat gar SFANT ATK AZT TF A-BT ATZAT F AAA HT gsr Hr feareae ada Fag-at ati afaaen a ae afafraiferfear fe grofefeafaalay cara Ftae gt fe orftaat Saar aaeat & ef, fe es ater otc AA F fw Fae aTATATANT FT AT HATS FH AegaRNIe Fart Fale area fears al Bar & at aedare Tey HY HrgaTet fara arratfeat ar afaar art arar seat ale gataaa areargal & gs sefaat are 81 (i) (at)Brey He H erfacaretar Ta aused faa F wea gt ate afrawr Age soars fafa F yea wt saatwa % fre Fata sea eararaa at fafese Hx fear aha ATT HT gu, fare aafteren ot Bar Bt frateor ad 1961-62 & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF ot Bar Bt frateor ad 1961-62 & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF Bar Bt frateor ad 1961-62 & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF Bt frateor ad 1961-62 & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF frateor ad 1961-62 & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF ad 1961-62 & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF 1961-62 & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF & 1963-64 % faaten B aaF 1963-64 % faaten B aaF % faaten B aaF faaten B aaF B aaF aaFF