Date Of Order - 9.4.2013 v. Nisha Gupta),J (Mohammad Rafiq),J

In the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthanat Jaipur Bench, Jaipur D.B.Civil Special Appeal (W) No.1004/2009in S.B.Civil Writ Petition No.11078/2008 Commissioner of Income Tax and another vs.M/S Antiquariat and Anr. Date of order - 9.4.2013 Hon'ble Mr.Justice Mohammad RafiqHon'ble Mrs. Justice Nisha Gupta Mr.JK Singhi with Mr. OP Pareek for theappellants. On hearing learned counsel for theappellants and after perusal of the impugnedjudgment,we find that controversy raised inthe present matter is squarely covered by thejudgment of Division Bench of this courtrendered in the case of Commissioner IncomeTax vs Hari Kishan Vijayvergia and another,[2011] 336 ITR 174 (Raj) in which this courthad upheld the common judgment dated13.8.2009. The writ petition in this case aswell as in the aforesaid judgment wasdismissed by the said judgment dated 13.8.2009. The present appeal is therefore alsodismissed for the reasons stated in theaforesaid judgment. (Nisha Gupta),J (Mohammad Rafiq),J om20 All corrections made in the judgment/order have been incorporated inthe judgment/order being emailed.the judgment/order being emailed. Om PrakashPA