Itxa/2666/2019 Of Pr. Commissioner Of Income Tax - 9 v. Atul Resorts And Hospitality India Pvt. Ltd

JPP IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION INCOME TAX APPEAL NO. 669 OF 2011 The Commissioner of Income Tax-II … Appellant V/s. Tukaram Krishnaji Pakale ... Respondent ALONGWITH INCOME TAX APPEAL NOS. 799/12, 1643/12, 281/13, 350/13,351/13, 377/13, 407/13, 1312/13, 382/13, 403/13, 406/13, 461/13,440/13, 441/13, 442/13, 470/13, 1575/13, 2135/13, 1789/114,1790/14, 1789/14, 1791/14, 134/15, 135/15, 916/15, 917/15,1028/15, 1034/15, 1060/15, 1156/15, 221/16, 1694/16, 1825/16,176/18, 386/18, 596/18, 660/18, 715/19, 729/19, 751/19, 753/19,971/19, 1402/19, 2080/13, 2113/13, 944/19, 1004/19, 1442/19,1697/19, 1420/19, 1711/19, 1861/19, 2514/19, 2517/19, 2520/19,2556/19, 2666/19, 2672/19, 2673/19, 2687/19, 2688/19, ITXALNos. 1271/18, 2935/18, 3422/18, 3630/18, 3714/18, 1125/18, andITXA No. 2447/19. INCOME TAX APPEAL NOS. 2885/18, 2904/18, 2909/18,2934/18, 2962/18, 2975/18, 3003/18, 3019/18, 3039/18,3046/18, 3063/18, Mr. Tejveer Singh Mastan Singh for the Appellants in ITXA Nos.669/11, 799/12, 1643/12, 281/13, 350/13, 351/13, 377/13, 407/13,1312/13, 382/13, 403/13, 406/13, 461/13, 440/13, 441/13, 442/13,470/13, 1575/13, 2135/13, 1789/114, 1790/14, 1789/14, 1791/14,134/15, 135/15, 916/15, 917/15, 1028/15, 1034/15, 1060/15,1156/15, 221/16, 1694/16, 1825/16, 176/18, 386/18, 596/18, 660/18, 715/19, 729/19, 751/19, 753/19, 971/19, 1402/19,2080/13, 2113/13, 944/19, 1004/19, 1442/19, 1697/19, 1420/19,1711/19, 1861/19, 2514/19, 2517/19, 2520/19, 2556/19, 2666/19,2672/19, 2673/19, 2687/19, 2688/19, ITXAL Nos. 1271/18,2935/18, 3422/18, 3630/18, 3714/18, 1125/18 and ITXA No.2885/18. Mr. A.R. Malhotra for the Appellant in ITXA No. 2447/19. Mr. Suresh Kumar for the Appellants in ITXA Nos. 2904/18,2909/18 and 3046/18 Mr. Akhileshwar Sharma for the Appellants in ITXA No. 2934/18. Mr. Sham Walve for the Appellants in ITXA Nos. 2962/18,3003/18, 3039/18, 3063/18 Mr. P.C. Chhotaray i/b. Arvind Pinto for the Appellant in ITXA No.2975/18. Mr. P.C. Chhotaray for the Appellant in ITXA No. 3019/18. Mr. Atul K. Jasani for the Respondents in ITXA Nos. 1312/13, 916/15, 917/15, 1028/15, 1034/15, 1060/15, 1711/19, 1861/19,2666/19, 3714/18, 1312/13, 2080/13 and 2904/18. Mr. B.V. Jhaveri for the Respondent in ITXA No. 1575/13 Mr. Abhishek Tilak for the Respondent in ITXA Nos. 2135/13,1694/15. Mr. Ruturaj H. Gurjar for the Respondents in ITXA Nos. 1789/14,1790/14, 221/16, 1402/19, 1789/14, 1791/14, 2113/13, 944/19,1004/19, 1442/19, 1697/19. Mr. Jas Sanghvi i/b. PDS Legal for the Respondents in ITXA Nos.2672/19, 2673/19 and ITXAL No. 1271/18 Ms. Rutuja N. Pawar a/w. S.C. Tiwari for the Respondent in ITXA2885/18. Mr. Srihari Iyer for the Respondent in ITXA No. 2909/18. Mr. Divyesh P. Fatoria i/b. Vipul B. Joshi for the Respondents inITXA No. 2962/18, 3003/18. Mr. Sameer Dalal for the Respondent in ITXA No. 3019/18. Mr. Rahul Hakani for the Respondent in ITXA no. 1420/19. P.C.:- CORAM : M.S. SANKLECHA & NITIN JAMDAR, JJ.DATE : 18 OCTOBER 2019. In these Appeals the learned Counsel appearing for the Appellants on instructions seeks to withdraw the Appeals. This forthe reason that the tax effect involved in all these Appeals is less thanthe threshold limit of Rs. 1.00 crore provided in the Central Boardfor Direct Taxes (CBDT) Circular No.17 of 2019 dated 8 August2019. 2.In the above view, all the Appeals are disposed of aswithdrawn. 3.Refund of Court fees as per Rules. NITIN JAMDAR, J. M. S. SANKLECHA, J .