In Mcc/623/2013 Of Assitant Commissioner Of Income Tax, Raipur v. South Eastern Coal Field Ltd. Bilaspur, the High Court (2013) allowed the appeal. The decision went in favour of the Revenue.
Summary auto-generated from the order below — read the full judgment for the complete reasoning.
§§§§E€ €E$B§? $F £§EE§$T§§$AR§ i? §Ei§3?£§§
§§¥i5i§3§l §§gg§1 :Qan‘hie Simi SuuE ii'gmar $§a§la &i‘im‘bia $§m’ E§ $h§r§éia§a5 $45-ig-Q‘C-[Ea!] *4” :é i533éggiiraiiaka;'amfannlagzmm{ifiarnmPTmgrcie—‘§ Raga:i‘im‘bia $§m’ E§ $h§r§éia§a5 $45-ig-Q‘C-[Ea!] *4” :é i533éggiiraiiaka;'amfannlagzmm{ifiarnmPTmgrcie—‘§ Raga:
33$.
E;igf2§-:.=5Smith Eagfem[{‘93]§t=lri3 Lit. Eii'éswr$§§3i§ga£im faé' rgitgraima i2f h; Sag i‘w. 5§i2§§§=$§§3i§ga£im faé' rgitgraima i2f h; Sag i‘w. 5§i2§§§=
P:&$&;‘i§:
$31: .éaargé {Ewaiiga kiwmta far 121a §p§§§£arsi
é § B E R{€2.§§E§?3}
Hegnj m i.[A]Riki}.
Thi3 i3 a?! apgikatign §ar wgdmatian m‘ a‘eiay in iii 3g thEiii $5
émngdéngm Q§Ece ramrithe i‘¢%.i3§. i2; §agred §y E (Saw.
f‘ :Lia LamidPi$m Q:[*313]wbmmgpwnq madEii}! £1? eamPd[PELQSP¥]hfihF a:im and i113[aimimig][ faggen][ in] ié}? aw watim § Aiiaii WE $3 gaiigieéhat mg agaémaai E153 aimgéa 3af§£§am :zalgsg Em W? 1€lmg iim Fé§£l iii §me argrjif”: éiliau’ é5a—w4iq %rigégnagi
§.A.F'ér.if§ 33 aiiijwed.
The &&iay 3r! 1§!§ng §1e iiCE. 3E mnécmeé.
agsiiéa'}[é1easé]an 1%i3[Ea][ E§3E§]
Tha aggiigagii;ekmg rewtergmm {If ?ai:33? {FR} £ic3h7i§ii{£321regiskfed 53 T33 {Egg 3%.,:§:'2{%‘§ Q} whmh ava§ di5a§5§u {Ha ammni a§ parempiawgs'éer @‘aEd $i-§3-E531 i3 a3 §1e {iefaLéE gminied taut by ihe {éEae Egg mt {armed wi§1iri‘hrae Winks: ‘&Pa‘ Em: dEiE m‘ E§rFrfrnurg :iFéF'.regiskfed 53 T33 {Egg 3%.,:§:'2{%‘§ Q} whmh ava§ di5a§5§u {Ha ammni a§ parempiawgs'éer @‘aEd $i-§3-E531 i3 a3 §1e {iefaLéE gminied taut by ihe {éEae Egg mt {armed wi§1iri‘hrae Winks: ‘&Pa‘ Em: dEiE m‘ E§rFrfrnurg :iFéF'.
iii: E‘laiiaiiya Sabmai’a mat éhere WEia tws éygfaaita. First wag it? mt fi§ka§ §1E”upy m‘ $§aesa§§am mée; aad §1e Ea ad wRE a§eut ”at Eatig ihe wmiiEcE mpg §§
faadilk
§1e imgtjgnsaé giéai. He suiiméig that ih$ mpy nf Asgassmmt[ Drx‘ier][ was]§§Eé[{m]€§-§3—2m§ ansi aanlicaian it}; exem§§m fmm iiiing :ha £§¥§i§£é my;[wag][ giaaj][ gm]‘E ‘—€"3—?f¥%{!‘%hPHrEWFyPr twig? imaa ‘imnmgFd thg aigmtg igx Fag?,;§1&,%e?& E§§§aaailga1s §§%eé :$—§3.2Qii3 aad §?'-£!3—2§‘éa[aiwg]with aaggaf£55§33mant mag; aie5:1 the recmig 9f $33 tax case. m Emiraai cimumsanaaii[ if]ihP-—r mgkaiégim ware Eiea‘ with§a iimia; §1£ maiar wsald haw bgea rafairéd' it: gigBari? baigagsa irEsh aiéar[1m]timw apgiiaatiaa’e: we€e[reqgiigd.]
In§iF¢v“W IiwahmgPB5? €"Nn[mif?m?]13aEirwgéargé?{Ejgg. .{.§_?‘E€}1§Imstageé ta ii: ar’g§a&§ mmi‘aei
Emiwa apg§icatiimg .rgfaireé t6 a§3m§e arg baiiig marked[a$][ Lei—1][ ané][ LA-]IR}M???§§1E{Faiwwinr*hF§§§v¥y=:is-[‘h]mg£a==ebgfzria aggmgiateEa’5LIEEQ‘:§s3r wje$933.. angiigaéjma
meé}: 5‘. fmE; g 3E[d]
i$§3§3gé at.
““Sd/-Sunil Kumar'SinhaJudgeJ?s°{:l
‘
‘
Sd/-Rangnath[‘Chanakar]drJudge
This page reproduces a public-domain court order (Section 52(1)(q)(iv), Copyright Act 1957). Explanations are EaseValue's original analysis. Always read the original order.
Disclaimer: General information only — not legal, tax or professional advice, and no advocate/CA–client relationship is created. AI-generated summaries may contain errors and must be verified against the original court order. EaseValue accepts no liability for reliance on this content. Not a solicitation.
Full disclaimer & Terms.