Case Law › Supreme Court › [1958] 1 S.C.R. 689

The Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. M/S. Mcmillan & Co

Supreme Court [1958] 1 S.C.R. 689 16 Oct 1957 In favour of: Revenue
Forum / Bench
Supreme Court
Parties
The Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. M/S. Mcmillan & Co
Date of order
16 Oct 1957
Assessment year(s)
—
Outcome
Allowed

Case analysis

⚙️ Auto-generated structured summary from the order — a quick research aid, not a hand-reviewed analysis. Read the original judgment below for authority.
In The Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. M/S. Mcmillan & Co, the Supreme Court (1957) allowed the appeal. The decision went in favour of the Revenue.
Legal topics
Business income
01

Issue for determination

Sections referenced in this judgment

Original judgment (source document)

The analysis above is EaseValue's editorial summary. Below is the court's original order, reproduced from the public record as a source document — the OCR text is cleaned for readability but may retain scanning artifacts; rely on the official source for the authentic version.
▸ Show the full original order (source text)
Section: CONCLUSION THE COMMISSIONER OF INCOME-TAX M/s. McMILLAN & CO. (BHAGWATI, S. K. DAs and J. L. KAPUR, JJ.) Income-Tax-Assessment-Acceptance by Income-tax Officer <f he assessee's method of accounting-Power of Appellate Assistant Commissioner in appeal-If can reject such method and adopt a11otlzer-India11 Income-tax Act (XI of 1922), ss. 31, 13 proviso--Indian Income-tax Rules, R. 33. The respondent assessee, a non-resident company, sold and published books and magazines in various parts of the world. lt submitted for the assessment year in question a return in which a :fixed percentage of the marked price. of all publications sold in India, printed in India or elsewhere, was adopted as the cost of production and this method of accounting was followed in the return. The Income-tax Officer accepting this method, assessed the income at Rs. 82,623. The assessee preferred an appeal on other grounds to the Appellate Assistant Commissioner. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner was of opinion that the true income of the assessee could not be deduced from the method of accounting followed by him and accepted by the Income-tax Officer and issued a notice under s. 31(3) of the Indian Income· tax Act and after hearing the assessee fixed his assessable income at Rs. 1,11,616 by applying the provisions of Rule 33 of the Indian Income-tax Rules. The assessee appealed to the Appellate Tribunal and the Tribunal, relying on a recent decision of the Bombay High Court, held that the Appellate Assistant Commis-sioner had no jurisdiction to enhance the income in the way he did and referred the matter to the High Court at the instance of the appellant. The High Court held against the appellant and he appealed. The questions for decision were whether it was open to the Appellate Assistant Commissioner in exercise of his powers under s. 31(3} of the Act to reject the .method of accounting, followed by the assessee and accepted by the Income-tax Officer, under the proviso to s. 13 of the Act, and compute the income, profits or gains of the assessee under Rule 33 of the Rules. Held, (per S. K. Das and Kapur. JJ., Bhagwati, J., dissenting) that the questions must be answered in the affirmative and the appeal must succeed. There is nothing ins. 31, read with the proviso to s. 13, of the Indian Income-tax Act which prevents the Appellate Assistant Commissioner, in an appeal preferred by the asscssee, from exercising the powers which the Income-tax Officer can exercise under the proviso to s. 13 of the Act. Although it is for the Income-tax Officer, in the first instance, to decide what would be the correct method of accounting under the proviso in a parti-cular case, he has, in doing so, to act reasonably and judicially and L2SC/61 P. V-7 Oc1ober, 16. 1957 not subjectively or arbitrarily and any decision he may arrive at --cannot be treati:d as final. Neither s. \J nor the proviso imposes The Commissioner any limitation on the wide powers conferred on the Appellate of Income-Tax Assistant Commissioner bys. 31(3) of the Act once he is in proper v. seizin of the matter. M/s. McMi/1011 Narrondas Manordass, Bombay v. Commissioner of Income-tax (1957) 31 J.T.R. 909, approved. K. F. Vakeel v. The Commissioner of Income-tax, l.T. Refer- ence No. 21 of 1950, Bombay High Court, dissented from. Case-law discussed. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner has also the power in an appeal to apply the provisions of Ruic 33 of the Indian Income-tax Rules for the purpose of a correct computation of the assessee's income although the Income-tax Officer has not done so. 689 690 1958 ] 1950 1957 1958 ] 1922 . 693 Per Bhagwati,.J.-The difference in the language of the tw<> conditions, on the fulfilment of which the meth<>d of accounting regularly employed by the assessee can be rejected under the proviso to s. 13 of the Indian ·Income-tax Act clearly indicates that the Legislature intended that any determination as to the second condition, namely, that the income, profits and gains of the assessee cannot be property deduced from the method regularly employed by him, must be of the Income-tax Officer atone and no other authority described in the hierarchy of Income-tax authori-ties and defined by the Act. K. F. Vakeel v. The Commissioner of Income-tax, J.T. Refer-ence No. 21 of 1950, Bombay High Court, approved. Nor are the powers of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner under s. 3 t (3) of the Act, in however wide terms they may have been described, absolute in character being circumscribed, as they necessarily are, by the nature of the pr<>ceedings before him and are limited to the subject-matter of the assessment. Narrondas Manordass, Bombay v. The Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay, (1957) 31 l.T.R. 909, referred to. Case-Jaw discussed. Section 31(3) of the Act has, therefore, to be read along with s. 13 and its proviso and so read there can be no doubt the Appellate Assistant Commissioner has no power fir appeal t<> nullify the power which the Income-tax Officer atone has under the proviso. He has no power to reject the method of accounting regularly employed by the assessee suo motu. If he thinks that the Income-tax Officer was in error in accepting that meth<>d as the proper method for computing the assessee's income what he can do is to set aside the assessment and direct the Income-tax Officer to make a fresh assessment under s. 31(3)(h) of the Act. Nor can he in exercising his power of enhancing the assessment under s. 31(3)(a) exercise the power under the proviso to s. 13 which is solely vested in the Income-tax Officer. The questions must, therefore, be answered in the negative. CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION. Civil Appeal No. The Co;;;;;;ssioner 29 of 1955; of Income-Tax Income-Tax of Income-Tax Income-Tax v. M/s. McMillan & Co. Appeal by special l~ave from the judgment and order dated the 14th March, 1953, of the Bombay High Court in Income-tax Reference No. 27 of 1952. Daphtary, Solicitor-General of India, G. N. Joshi and R.H. D.hebar, for the appellant. N. A. Palkhivala, J. B. Dadachanji, S. N. Andley, Rameshwar Nath and P. L. Vohra,'for the respondents. 1957. October l6. The judgment of S. K. Das and J. L. Kapur JJ. was delivered by S. K. Das J. Bhag-wati J. delivered a separate judgment. s. K. Dasi. S. K. DAS J.-This is an appeal by special leave from the judgment and order of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay, dated March ~. 1953, in Income-tax Reference No. 27 of 1952, by· which the said High Court answered certain questions of law referred to it in the negative. The answer to those questions depends upon the true scope and effect of certain provisions of the Indian Income-tax Act (XI of 1922), hereinafter referred as the Act, regarding which t:bere has already been a difference of opinion between two High Courts in India. Unfortunately, we have come to a conclusion different from that of our learned senior brother Bhagwati J., and we are explaining in this judgment, as briefly and clearly as we can, the grounds on which our conclusion is founded. Very briefly put, the relevant facts are these. The 1922 . 693 1958 ] 695 assessee, respondent before us, is a non-resident com-· pany which has its head office in London and branches in India. It sells and publishes books and magazines in various parts of the world. For the assessment year in question, it submitted a return of income in which with regard to all publications sold in India, whether printed in India or elsewhere, a fixed per-centage of what was known as the marked price was adopted as the cost of production. This, if one may so put it, was the method of accounting on which the assesseo company submitted its return. The Income- 692 ta Offi 1957 . _ .cer apparently accepted it . . and subject to cer- . _ ~ .cer apparently accepted it . . and subject to cer-IThe Commissioner tam mmor modifications as respects some items of of Income-Tax expenditure and an alleged bad debt with whieh we v. are not now concerned, assessed the assessee on an M/s. McMillan income of Rs. 82,623. The assessee appealed to the & Co. Appellate Assistant Commissioner. The latter issued s. K. Das 1. a notice under s. 31(3) of the Act against the assessee. and after hearing the assessee, enhanced the assess-ment of the assessee company's business income to Rs. 1,ll,616. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner found: · "It is noticed that on total turnover of Rs. 16,01,973 for the previous year ending 30th May, 1943, the gross profit amounted to Rs. 4,09,360 working out to just about 25.5 per ceni. In the case of World profit and loss account I find that the gross profit earned was £ 231,070 on total sales of £ 628,000 working out to over 37 per cent. The difference in gross profit is so wide that some explanation had to be called for from the appellants, especially in view of the fact that the appellants do not maintain what should be called an Indian trading and profit and loss account on the same lines as the World trading and profit and loss account~ The profit and loss account maintained in India shows only the purchases at the rate at which these were charged to the Indian branches by the London head office instead of the real cost of these publications." He was of the view that inasmuch as the fixed percent-age of the marked price adopted by the assessee com-pany as the production cost for its publications sold in India did not correctly represent .the actual cost of production, the method of accounting regularly em-ployed is such that a true figure of income, profits and gains is not deducible therefrom. He fixed the income of the assessee company on the basis of the net world profit of the assessee on its world turnover, and applying that basis to its Indian business came to the conclusion that the income of the assessee was Rs. 1,11,616. He did so presumably under the proviso to s. i3 and R. 33 of the Indian Income-tax Rules, 1922. The assessee company then appealed to the Appel-1957 late Tribunal. The Appellate Tribunal remanded the Ti'h c-·.., C . . b e omm1s •• •• oner case o t th e A ppe ate 11 A ss1s [•t ]ant omm1ss1oner, ut of Income-Tax Income-Tax before the remand could be decided came the decision v. of the Bombay High Court in K. F. Vakeel v. The M/s.McMillan Commissioner of Income-tax(1). The Tribunal then & Co. held that in view of that decision, the Appellate Assis-s. K. Das 1. tant Commissioner rad no jurisdiction to enhance the income to Rs. 1,11,616. Thereafter, the Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay City, appellant before us, asked the Tribunal to submit certain questions of law to the High Court of Bombay. These questions were- e omm1s •• •• oner of Income-Tax Income-Tax v. "(1) Whether it is open to an Appellate Assistant Commissioner on appeal to reject the assessee':; books of account, which have been accepted by the Income-tax Officer ? (2) Whether it is open to an Appellate Assistant Commissioner on appeal to invoke the provisions of Rule 33 of the Indian Income-tax Rules for the pur-pose of computing the income· of a non-resident, the Income-tax Officer not having done so ? 697 (3) Whether it is open to an Appellate Assistant Commissioner on appeal to enhance an assessment in exercise of the powers conferred upon him by sec-tion 31(3)(a) of the Indian Income-tax Act, where as a result of definite information he is of opinion that the in.come of the assessee has been under-assessed ?" By its judgment and order dated March 4, 1953, the High Court answered the first two questions in the negative and held-rightly in our view-that the third question did not arise. The appellant then asked for and obtained special leave to appeal from the said judgment and order of the Bombay High Court. The first question appears to us to have been some:. what widely framed and, in the terms in which it has been expressed, is not confined to the method of ac-counting referred to in s. 13 of the Act. The Tucome-tax Officer, even when he accepts the assessee's method of accounting, is not bound by the figure of pro-fits shown in the accounts. If and when an appeal is 1957 taken by the assessee to the Appellate Assistant Com-The CommissloMr missioner, the latter can re-examine the books of of Income-Tax account to test the correctness of the assessment made. v. It is not disputed before us that 'accounts' must be M/•. McMillan distinguished from the 'method of accounting'. Sec-& co. tion 13 and its proviso are concerned with the method s. K. Das J. of accounting. In the context of the statement of the case, however, the fil'St question really means this : is it open to the Appellate_ Assistant Commissioner, on an appeal preferred by the assessee, to reject for the first time the method of accounting, purporting to act under the proviso to s. 13 of the Act, on the ground that the income, profits and gains cannot be properly deduced therefrom, .when the Income-tax Officer although he has not expressly said so must be taken to have accepted the self-same method of accounting ? The answer to the question depends on a correct interpretation of ss. 13 and 31 of the Act. We shall first read s. 13 of the Act : "13. Income, profits and gains shall be computed, for the purposes of sections 10 and 12, in acl!ordance with the method of accounting regularly employed by the nssessee : Provided that, if no method of accounting has been regularly employed, or if the method employed is such that, in the opinion of the Income-tax Officer, the income, profits and gains cannot properly be deduced therefrom, then the computation shall be made upon such basis and in such manner as the Income-tax Officer may determine." The section enacts that for the purposes of s. 10 (pro- . fits of business, profession or vocation) and s. 12 (in-come from other sources) income, profits and gains must be computed in accordance with the method of accounting regularly employed by the assessee. Th<! choice of the method of accounting lies with the asses-see; but the assessee must show that he has followed the method regularly for his own purposes. The sec-tion and the proviso read together clearly make such a method of accounting regularly employed by the assessee a compulsory basis of computation unless, in the opinion of the Income-tax Officer, the income, pro-fits and gains cannot properly be deduced therefrom. 1957 If the true income, profits and gains cannot be ascer- fained on the basis of the assessee's method, or where Tiie c~ssloirtr no method of accounting has been regularly employed, of /11come-Tax the income must be computed upon such basis and in v. such manner as the Income-tax Officer may determine. M/s. McMillan Thus far, there is no divergence of opinion as to
Facing a similar income-tax issue?
Our CA-led litigation team handles notices, scrutiny, penalties and appeals (CIT(A) & ITAT) end-to-end.
✅ File an income-tax appeal (CIT(A)/ITAT) → 💬 Ask our CA
This page reproduces a public-domain court order (Section 52(1)(q)(iv), Copyright Act 1957). Explanations are EaseValue's original analysis. Always read the original order.
Disclaimer: General information only — not legal, tax or professional advice, and no advocate/CA–client relationship is created. AI-generated summaries may contain errors and must be verified against the original court order. EaseValue accepts no liability for reliance on this content. Not a solicitation. Full disclaimer & Terms.
Contact Careers Media / Press · Privacy Terms Refund Cancellation Cookies Disclaimer
© 2026 EaseValue Payment Solution Private Limited · CIN U66190RJ2025PTC109642 · Jaipur, Rajasthan