The Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Shri S.v. Mhatre & Ors
High Court
17 Oct 2005 In favour of: Unclear
Forum / Bench
High Court · newos
Parties
The Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Shri S.v. Mhatre & Ors
Date of order
17 Oct 2005
Assessment year(s)
—
Outcome
Other
The order — as passed by the High Court
Case summary
In The Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Shri S.v. Mhatre & Ors, the High Court (2005) decided the matter.
Summary auto-generated from the order below — read the full judgment for the complete reasoning.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO. 51 OF 1997.
The Commissioner of Income-tax.
vs.
Shri S.V. Mhatre & ors.
..Applicant...Respondents
Shri Parag Vyas with Ashok Kotangale and A.S. Raofor the applicant.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO. 66 OF 1997
The Commissioner of Income taxvs.Devichandsa Dhullichansa FamilyTrust. .. Respondents.
.. Applicant.
Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
Shri Pramod Vaidya i/b S.N.Inamdar for therespondent.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO.68 OF 1997.
The Commissioner of Income Tax.
vs.
M/s Amity Agrovet Industries P.Ltd.. ..Respondent./
.. Aplicant.
Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO. 69 OF 1997
The Commissioner of Income Tax.
vs.
M/s Jay Ambe Supari Centre.
Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
..Applicant.
..Respondent.
AND
The Commissioner of Income-tax.
vs.
Dr.A.M.Gokhale.
..Applicant.
..Respondent.
Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO. 82 OF 1997.
The Commissioner of Income-tax.
vs.
National Garage P.Ltd.
..Applicant...Respondent.
Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO. 89 OF 1997.
The Commissioner of Income-tax.
vs.
Shri Ramkrishna Bajaj
..Applicant...Respondent.
Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO. 130 OF 1997.
The Commissioner of Income-tax.
vs.
The Trustees of Sir JamsetjiJeejeebhoy Charity Fund.
..Applicant.
..Respondent.
Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO. 146 OF 1997.
The Commissioner of Income-tax.
vs.
M/s Vegetable Vitaminfood Co. P.Ltd.
..Applicant.
..Respondent.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO. 168 OF 1997.
The Commissioner of Income-tax.vs.M/s International DataManagement P.Ltd.
..Applicant.
..Respondent.
Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO. 210 OF 1997
The Commissioner of Income-tax. ..Applicant.
vs.M/s Sanghi Motors P.Ltd...Respondent.
Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the Applicant.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO. 236 OF 1997.
The Commissioner of Income-tax...Applicant.vs.Shri Atul Kamath..Respondent.Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO.244 OF 1997.
The Commissioner of Income-tax...Applicant.vs.Shri Saeed-Al-Rafaie...Respondent.Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO.249 OF 1997.
vs.
M/s B.P. (India Agencies) Ltd.
..Applicant.
..Respondent.
Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO. 295 OF 1997.
The Commissioner of Income-tax.vs.Padamshi Meghji
..Applicant.
..Respondent.
Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO. 309 OF 1997.
The Commissioner of Income-tax. ..Applicant.
vs.
Shri Jitrendra J. Modi
..Respondent.
Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO. 324 OF 1997.
The Commissioner of Income-tax.vs.All India Reporter Ltd.Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
..Applicant...Respondent.
CORAM : V.C.DAGA AND J.P. DEVADHAR,JJ.
DATED : 17.10.2005.
P.C. :----
this Court in the case of C.I.T. vs. Camco ColourCo.(2002) 254 ITR 565, we do not think itnecessary to answer the references made to thisCourt having negligible tax effect. Accordingly,
..Applicant.
..Respondent.
Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO. 309 OF 1997.
The Commissioner of Income-tax. ..Applicant.
vs.
Shri Jitrendra J. Modi
..Respondent.
Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
AND
INCOME TAX REFERENCE NO. 324 OF 1997.
The Commissioner of Income-tax.vs.All India Reporter Ltd.Shri Parag Vyas with Shri Ashok Kotangale and A.S.Rao for the applicant.
..Applicant...Respondent.
CORAM : V.C.DAGA AND J.P. DEVADHAR,JJ.
DATED : 17.10.2005.
P.C. :----
this Court in the case of C.I.T. vs. Camco ColourCo.(2002) 254 ITR 565, we do not think itnecessary to answer the references made to thisCourt having negligible tax effect. Accordingly,
all the references stand returned unanswered with no
order as to costs.
(J.P.DEVADHAR, J.)
(V.C.DAGA, J.)
This page reproduces a public-domain court order (Section 52(1)(q)(iv), Copyright Act 1957). Explanations are EaseValue's original analysis. Always read the original order.
Disclaimer: General information only — not legal, tax or professional advice, and no advocate/CA–client relationship is created. AI-generated summaries may contain errors and must be verified against the original court order. EaseValue accepts no liability for reliance on this content. Not a solicitation.
Full disclaimer & Terms.
EaseValue