Wp/17698/2011 Of K.bhaskar Prasad Rao, And 3 Others v. The Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax And 34 Others

HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANAAT HYOERABAD(Special Original Jurisdiction) THURSDAY,THE SIXTEENTH DAY OF MARCHTWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY THREE PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVILIANDTHE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK WRIT PETITION NO 17698 0F 2011 Between: 'l . K.Bhaskar Prasad Rao, S/o.late K.Rama Mohna rao, Aged about 51 yearslncome tax officer Ward -8 [('1 ]) O/o.the Addl.Commissioner of lncome taxRange-8 Bth floor,D-Block,lncome tax towers,Masab TanA. C.Guards, Hyderabad-500004lncome tax officer Ward -8 [('1 ]) O/o.the Addl.Commissioner of lncome taxRange-8 Bth floor,D-Block,lncome tax towers,Masab TanA. C.Guards, Hyderabad-500004 2. N.Parthasarathy, s/o.Late N.nagoor, aged about 48 [years, ]lncome tax officer,IVard No.2 Ayakar Bhavan [Near Kambal Cheruvu, Rajahmundry]IVard No.2 Ayakar Bhavan [Near Kambal Cheruvu, Rajahmundry] 3. P.Ram Babu, s/o.P.Nageswara Rao, aged about 54 [years, ][Tax ][Recovery]officer, -3, O/o.the Addl.Commissioner of lncome tax Range-3 Room No.B33D-Block,lncome tax towers, Masab Tan A.C.Guards,Hyderabad-500004officer, -3, O/o.the Addl.Commissioner of lncome tax Range-3 Room No.B33D-Block,lncome tax towers, Masab Tan A.C.Guards,Hyderabad-500004 4. G.V.Subrahmanyam, S/o.Ranga Rao, aged about 46 [years, ][lnspector ][of]lncome Tax O/o.the Addl.Commissioner of lncome tax Range-6 lncome taxTowers,Tth floor, D Block Masab Tank A.C.Guards,Hyderabad-500004lncome Tax O/o.the Addl.Commissioner of lncome tax Range-6 lncome taxTowers,Tth floor, D Block Masab Tank A.C.Guards,Hyderabad-500004 ...PETITIONERS AND The Chief Commissioner Of lncome Tax, Andhra Pradesh,Hyderabad 1. The Chairman, Central Board of Direct Taxes, North Blcok, New Delhi 2. 3.Union of lndia., rep.by Secretary, Govt of lndia Dept of, Revenue ,NorthBlock, New DelhiBlock, New Delhi The Secretary ,Dept of Personnel & Training,North Block, [New ][Delhi] 4. 5M.Kishore Babu, lncome Tax officer,OSD,. O/o.Addl.Commisisoner of lncomeTax, Range-2, VisakhapatnamTax, Range-2, Visakhapatnam T.Rama Rao, S/o.and age not known ITO [(OSD) ]O/o.lTO, [(lAP) Rajahmundry] 6. 7S.Swarnalatha Devi, D/o.and age not known ITO(OSD) O/o.Addl.ClT, [Range]13 Hyderabad13 Hyderabad 8K.Suresh Babu, Sio.and age not known ITO(OSD) O/o.Addl.ClT, [Range 6]GunturGuntur IK.Silvan Raju, S/o.and age not xnown tiOlOSD) O/o.Addl.ClT, [Range ][I]GunturGuntur 10.K.Deshpal Iiir'th, S/o.and age not known ITO(OS[)) O/o ,l{)lT Nellore 11. K.V.S.Gupta, [;;/o.and ]age not known ITO(OSD)-IV' Addl OlT Central Range-lHyderabadHyderabad 12. t\,4.Lalitha, D/,r arrd age not known ITO(OSD)- Addl ClT [(:,:rttral ]Range-2HyderabadHyderabad '13. G.RaghLrvare )r;lsad, D/o.and age not known ITOTOSDI-l Adc l.ClT CentralRange-l Hy< > akradRange-l Hy< > akrad 14. R.Gangadh;r [' ]rF ao, D/o.and age not known ITO(C)SD)-l [r-)/o.l ]fO [(TDS)-2]TirupathiTirupathi 15. J.seshacri S;tri rnra, S/o.and age not known ITO(OSD) O4: [lTCt ]officeGudivadaGudivada 16.N.Narasimha, 3/r.and age not known ITO(OSD) O/o.Ad,1 .3lT Rajahmundry lT.Solomon Serl rel Edwin, S/o.and age not known ITO(OS I) [r ]O/o.Addl.ClTRange -l Vis;aI htrpatnamRange -l Vis;aI htrpatnam 18.K.M.V.S Kurri r, S/o.and age not known ITO(OSD)-ll O/trlr,ddl.ClT Range -lHyderabadHyderabad '19.A.B.Gop,nalh, S/o.and age not known ITO(OSD)-l O/o.COlT Hyderabad-l 20. R.N.B.S.Manrt [.ri, ]S/o.and age not known ITO(OSDD) O/).,t\dd .ClT Range-6'.Visakhapatr zrr t'.Visakhapatr zrr t 21. [t/d.Nzaseernu ldin, S/o.and age not known ITO(OSD)-ll Oro.Addl.ClT Range-6 Hyderabarl6 Hyderabarl 22.M.Chandra 3c uci, S/o.and age not known ITO(OSD) Oic.tlGll'(lnv)HyderabadHyderabad 23.S.V.Prasad, ll o.and age not known ITO(OSD)-Il O/o.CClT HyJerabad-1 24. M.Viswanad l-: 'r S/o.and age not known ITO(OSD)-V Oio.Adrll.ClT CentralRange-l Hycler lbadRange-l Hycler lbad 25. K.Noor Ahmec Si/o.and age not known ITO(OSD)-i O/o.,\ddl.()lT Range-1 5Hyderab;adHyderab;ad 18.K.M.V.S Kurri r, S/o.and age not known ITO(OSD)-ll O/trlr,ddl.ClT Range -lHyderabadHyderabad '19.A.B.Gop,nalh, S/o.and age not known ITO(OSD)-l O/o.COlT Hyderabad-l 20. R.N.B.S.Manrt [.ri, ]S/o.and age not known ITO(OSDD) O/).,t\dd .ClT Range-6'.Visakhapatr zrr t'.Visakhapatr zrr t 21. [t/d.Nzaseernu ldin, S/o.and age not known ITO(OSD)-ll Oro.Addl.ClT Range-6 Hyderabarl6 Hyderabarl 22.M.Chandra 3c uci, S/o.and age not known ITO(OSD) Oic.tlGll'(lnv)HyderabadHyderabad 23.S.V.Prasad, ll o.and age not known ITO(OSD)-Il O/o.CClT HyJerabad-1 24. M.Viswanad l-: 'r S/o.and age not known ITO(OSD)-V Oio.Adrll.ClT CentralRange-l Hycler lbadRange-l Hycler lbad 25. K.Noor Ahmec Si/o.and age not known ITO(OSD)-i O/o.,\ddl.()lT Range-1 5Hyderab;adHyderab;ad 26.V.Leela Kunr;l i, l/o.and age not known ITO(OSD)-Il O/c.Addl CIT Range-15Hyderab;ldHyderab;ld 2T.V.Sivanandarr [)/o.and age not known ITO(OSD) O/o.A [jdl.ClT ]Kurnool 28. R.Supriya, t)/c R.Prabhakar lncome Tax officer O/o.Addl.tl;cmtnissioner oflncome Tax (q idit) l.T.Towers, [\/asab Tank Hyderabadlncome Tax (q idit) l.T.Towers, [\/asab Tank Hyderabad 29.V.Bhaskara Fli o, S/o.Veerraju lncome Tax lnspector O/c.l)om'nisisoner oflncome l-ax ll T Towers, lrlasab Tank Hyderabadlncome l-ax ll T Towers, lrlasab Tank Hyderabad 30. C.M.Chandras .'k1ara Reddy, S/o.Late C.Muni Reddy lncc,r're [--ax ]lnspectorO/o.Addl Conrr [-rir;sioner ]of lncome Tax Rangb-16 Ayakar Eihavan,Basheerbagh, I Iy,jerabadO/o.Addl Conrr [-rir;sioner ]of lncome Tax Rangb-16 Ayakar Eihavan,Basheerbagh, I Iy,jerabad 31. Sri.Bheerner;rv rra Prasad Dubey, S/o.late Satyanarayanir l:'rasad Dubeylncome l-ax CX'icer lncome Tax office Opp:Railway Statirrrr Warangallncome l-ax CX'icer lncome Tax office Opp:Railway Statirrrr Warangal 32. D.Govindarajulu, S/o.Sri.D.Venkateswarlu lnspector O/o.Additional CITRange-7 HyderabadRange-7 Hyderabad 33.A.P.Vijay Chander, S/o.Sri A.H.Prabhakar Rao lnspector of lncome TaxO/o.Director of lncome Tax (lnv) 9th floor, Ayakar bhavan, Basheerbagh,HyderabadO/o.Director of lncome Tax (lnv) 9th floor, Ayakar bhavan, Basheerbagh,Hyderabad 34. Sri.G.Benarjee, S/o.Lokanadham lncome Tax lnspector O/o.lTOSangareddy, Medak DistrictSangareddy, Medak District 35.The Central Administratlve Tribunal, rep.by the Registrar, HACA Bhavan,HyderabadHyderabad (Respondents 5 to 31 are not Necessary parties to this writ petition) ...RESPONDENTS Petition under Article 226 ol lhe Constitution of lndia praying that in thecircumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may bepleased to issue a direction order or writ more particularly one in the nature ofwrit of Certiorari calling for the records related to and connected with OriginalApplication no.1092 of 2009 dated 28.4.201 ['1 ]on the file of the learned CentralAdministrative Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench, Hyderabad and set aside the same_Application no.1092 of 2009 dated 28.4.201 ['1 ]on the file of the learned CentralAdministrative Tribunal, Hyderabad Bench, Hyderabad and set aside the same_ t.A. NOOF 2011{WPMP. NO: 21289 OF 2011) Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances statedin the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased tosuspend the operation of the order daled 28.4.2O'1 1 in Original ApplicationNo.1 092 of 2009 on the f ile of the learned Central Administrative TribunalHyderabad Bench, Hyderabad so as to refrain the official respondents fromreviewing the promotions made and to pass consider the cases of the petitionersfor being promoted as lncome Tax officers. Counsel for the Petitioners: SMT. GODA RAMALAKSHMI Counsel for the Respondent No.3 and 4: GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR (Dy.soltctToR GENERAL OF tNDtA) Counsel for the Respondent No.12: SRI.B. NARASIMHA SARMA The Court made the following: ORDER THE HON'Bt E SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAT. SHAVILIANDTHE IION'BLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KAR]'I{IK l,VPETIIIoN No. 1 7698 QE20 1 I ORDER: [(per ]I i s, ) Counsel for the Petitioners: SMT. GODA RAMALAKSHMI Counsel for the Respondent No.3 and 4: GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR (Dy.soltctToR GENERAL OF tNDtA) Counsel for the Respondent No.12: SRI.B. NARASIMHA SARMA The Court made the following: ORDER THE HON'Bt E SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAT. SHAVILIANDTHE IION'BLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KAR]'I{IK l,VPETIIIoN No. 1 7698 QE20 1 I ORDER: [(per ]I i s, ) Despitr: listing the matter under the [( ]i. pti ln 'for dismissal', tl- er e is no representation for the [petitiorr:.s.] 2. In viev/ [( ]F [l:he ]same, this Court has no other o:,iorr exceptto dismiss the A/'it Petition for default or non-l)rose :Lrtion. 3. Accordrrt, tl)', the Writ Petition is dismissed f tr default.There shall be rc order as to costs. Miscell,rn lcus Petitions, if any, pending ln this Writ Petition shall r;i arrd closed I;d/.I(.VENKAIAHASSIS'rANr liS,E 3TION OFFICER //TRUE COPY// To 1. One CC to [Sri. ] [ioda ][Ramalakshmi' Advocate ][ 2. One CC [to Sri, ] [a,ri ][praveJriii"u.ri ][tO,--soiicitor ][Gerieral ][,.rf ][ln ][jia) ] 5. o;; cc io [Sri. ] [I'larasimha ][Sarma, ][Advocate ][[oPUC]]4. Two CD CoPit:r; TJ,/(/ HIGH COURI- DATED:1610iii2023 ORDER WP.No.1769t) of 2011 Il'i:l rA [, ].-- c/./ ^(i.[\]i:)I')t, 5 l\i\ [l[fl]t)' ./ DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION [IT)EI=AULT] WITHOUT C(: STS. I ou/pr1>.9-'<