What Happened?
The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) Kolkata has recently ruled that the Assessing Officer (AO) cannot disallow 20% of claimed expenses as an ad hoc disallowance without pointing out specific defects or errors in the taxpayer's books of accounts or expense claims. This judgment, delivered in November 2026, marks an important protection for taxpayers against arbitrary and blanket disallowances during tax assessments for AY 2026-27 and onwards.
The tribunal held that any disallowance of expenses must be based on concrete findings and not on presumptive or ad hoc basis when the taxpayer's records appear complete and reliable.
Background & Legal Context
Relevant Sections Under Income Tax Act 2025:
- Section 37(1) of IT Act 2025: Allows deduction of expenses incurred wholly and exclusively for the purpose of business or profession. This is the primary section under which business expenses are claimed.
- Section 143(3) of IT Act 2025: Governs the assessment procedure and the AO's powers to make additions and disallowances. The AO must follow due process and have reasonable basis for any disallowance.
- Section 37 (old Section 1961 equivalent): The principle remains unchanged from the earlier Income Tax Act 1961 β expenses must be directly related to business operations and supported by documentary evidence.
What Was the Issue?
Many Assessing Officers have been following a practice of disallowing a flat 20% of expenses claimed by taxpayers, treating this as an "ad hoc disallowance." The rationale given was that all business expenses cannot be 100% accurate, so a portion should be disallowed as a matter of practice or precedent from past assessments.
The ITAT Kolkata has now firmly rejected this approach. The tribunal's reasoning is straightforward: if the taxpayer has maintained proper books of accounts, produced bills, invoices, and supporting documents, and the AO has not identified any specific defect or misclassification, then a blanket 20% disallowance is arbitrary and unjustifiable.
The Legal Principle Applied:
Under Section 143(3) of IT Act 2025, the AO has the power to make additions or disallowances, but this power is not uncontrolled. The Supreme Court and various High Courts have consistently held that:
- Any disallowance must have a rational basis and documentary support.
- The burden of proof lies on the Revenue (AO) to establish that expenses were not incurred or were not for business purposes.
- Ad hoc or round-tripping disallowances without specific findings are not tenable in law.
What Does This Mean for You?
For Business Owners and Self-Employed Professionals:
This ruling is a significant win. It means:
- Protection Against Arbitrary Disallowances: If you have properly documented all your business expenses with bills, invoices, and bank statements, the AO cannot simply disallow 20% without giving reasons. During assessment for AY 2026-27 and future years, you can cite this judgment if the AO attempts a blanket disallowance.
- Burden Shifts to Revenue: The AO must now specifically point out which expense is questionable, why it is questionable, and provide evidence that it was not incurred for business purposes.
- Strengthens Your Appeal Position: If during assessment the AO makes a 20% ad hoc disallowance without specific findings, you can immediately appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals) and later to ITAT citing this Kolkata ruling.
For CA and Tax Professionals:
This judgment should be referenced in audit reports and in letters to clients during the assessment process:
- When representing clients before the AO, cite this ruling to resist arbitrary disallowances.
- Ensure your client's books are audited and all expenses are properly classified and documented.
- During assessment objections, file detailed written submissions with this case reference.
For Assessees in AY 2026-27 and Beyond:
This ruling applies to all ongoing and future assessments. If you are currently facing or will face assessments for AY 2026-27, AY 2027-28, etc., you can rely on this judgment to challenge any 20% ad hoc disallowance without specific defects.
Important Note: This does NOT mean the AO cannot disallow expenses. It simply means disallowances must be specific, reasoned, and supported by evidence.
What Should You Do Now?
- Review Past Assessments: If you have already faced a 20% ad hoc disallowance in assessments for AY 2024-25, AY 2025-26, or earlier years without specific findings, consider filing an appeal or revision petition before the Commissioner. This ruling strengthens your case.
- Maintain Proper Records: Going forward, ensure every expense is:
- Supported by original bills/invoices.
- Properly classified in the books (under the correct expense head).
- Linked to business operations with documentary proof.
- Uploaded in e-filing system during tax return filing.
- Engage a CA Before Assessment: If you receive an assessment notice for AY 2026-27 or beyond, have your CA prepare a detailed response before the AO makes any additions. Reference this ruling proactively.
- File Strong Objections: If the AO still makes a 20% disallowance despite proper documentation, file detailed written objections with case reference and legal reasoning. Do not accept it passively.
- Keep Documentation Ready: Maintain a summary sheet of all major expenses showing supporting documents. This makes it easy to present during assessment and strengthens your position.
Key Takeaways
- ITAT Kolkata (Nov 2026): Ad hoc 20% expense disallowance is invalid without specific defects or findings by the Assessing Officer.
- Section 143(3) IT Act 2025: The AO's power to disallow is not unlimited; it must be based on rational, documented, and reasoned findings.
- Practical Impact: Taxpayers with proper books and documentary support can now confidently resist arbitrary disallowances during assessment for AY 2026-27 and onwards.
- What AO Must Do: Identify specific expenses, explain why they are questionable, and provide evidence supporting disallowance β not round-tripping percentages.
- Your Action: Maintain meticulous records, cite this ruling if challenged, and engage a qualified CA to represent you during assessment.
Need expert help with this? EaseValue CAs in Jaipur β WhatsApp 84400 44833
EaseValue