What Happened?
The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) at Jodhpur has delivered an important ruling that HUF (Hindu Undivided Family) can render commission services and earn income through its Karta (manager) or members without violating tax laws. This judgment, delivered in November 2026, clarifies a long-standing ambiguity about whether HUF is permitted to undertake commission-based business activities. The tribunal ruled that there is no legal bar to an HUF earning commission income, provided the income is properly recorded and taxed in the HUF's hands or distributed among members as per HUF rules.
Background & Legal Context
Under the Income Tax Act 2025, an HUF is treated as a separate entity for tax purposes, distinct from its individual members. Section 2(31) of the Income Tax Act 2025 defines an HUF as a family living together and governed by Hindu law, including Hindus, Buddhists, Jains, and Sikhs. The HUF can earn income from various sources, including business, profession, salary, and other sources.
However, the concept of HUF rendering commission services has often been questioned by tax authorities, particularly when:
- The Karta or members act as commission agents or intermediaries
- Commission income is earned through personal efforts of the Karta
- There is no formal business structure or registration
The ITAT Jodhpur ruling addresses these concerns by establishing that HUF is a competent entity to undertake commission-based activities. This aligns with the broader principle under Section 4(1) of the Income Tax Act 2025, which states that income tax is levied on the total income of any person, including HUF, arising in India or accruing to him during the financial year.
Key Sections Involved:
- Section 2(31), IT Act 2025: Definition of Hindu Undivided Family
- Section 4(1), IT Act 2025: Charge of income tax on HUF as a person
- Section 14, IT Act 2025: Income from business or profession (where commission services fall)
- Section 27, IT Act 2025: Clubbing of income earned by minor children (if applicable)
- Old Section 60, IT Act 1961: Still applies for income earned by members
The judgment is relevant for Assessment Year 2026-27 onwards, though HUFs filing returns for earlier years may also benefit from this clarification in case of pending disputes.
What Does This Mean for You?
For HUF Members Earning Commission:
If your HUF or the Karta earns commission income (whether from broking services, real estate intermediation, insurance commission, or similar activities), this ruling provides legal support to claim that such income belongs to the HUF. This is beneficial because:
- Lower Tax Rate: HUF has its own tax slab, which may be lower than individual tax rates depending on other income sources
- Legitimate Business: The ruling removes the cloud of doubt over whether HUF can engage in commission-based activities
- Deductions & Expenses: Commission income earned by HUF allows deduction of business expenses, travel costs, and professional fees under Section 30-37 of IT Act 2025
- Loss Offset: If HUF incurs loss in commission business, it can be offset against other HUF income
For Tax Authorities:
The ruling sets a binding precedent for ITAT Jodhpur region (Rajasthan, Gujarat, parts of Madhya Pradesh). Tax authorities must now accept HUF commission income claims if properly documented. However, authorities will still scrutinize:
- Whether the commission is genuine and earned by the HUF (not diverted personal income)
- Proper documentation and invoicing in HUF name
- Whether income is commensurate with efforts and market rates
- Compliance with GST requirements (if applicable)
Practical Impact for AY 2026-27:
HUF members who render commission services should now:
- Issue invoices in the HUF's name, not personal name
- Maintain a separate bank account for HUF commission income
- File ITR as HUF if total income exceeds the threshold
- Claim appropriate business deductions under IT Act 2025 sections 30-37
- Register for GST if turnover exceeds the threshold, filing returns as HUF
What Should You Do Now?
Step 1: Review Your HUF Structure
If your HUF is currently earning commission income, review whether it is properly documented. If the income is currently being claimed in the name of Karta as individual income, consider restructuring for future years (AY 2026-27 onwards).
Step 2: Proper Documentation
Going forward, ensure all commission agreements, invoices, and payment receipts are in the HUF's name. Use a formal commission statement that clearly identifies the HUF as the service provider. Maintain records showing that the HUF (through Karta's efforts) earned the commission.
Step 3: Bank Account & Accounting
Maintain a separate bank account for HUF commission income. This demonstrates that the income belongs to the HUF as an entity. Use proper accounting software and maintain GST-compliant records if GST registration is mandatory.
Step 4: GST Compliance
Commission services are taxable under GST at 18% (depending on the nature of service). If the HUF's turnover exceeds βΉ40 lakh (βΉ20 lakh for specific states), GST registration is mandatory. Register the HUF as a separate taxpayer with its own GSTIN.
Step 5: ITR Filing for AY 2026-27
File ITR as HUF (Form ITR-3 is typically used for business income). Claim all legitimate business deductions, including office expenses, travel, professional fees, depreciation on assets used for earning commission. Report commission income under Section 14 (Business or Profession).
Step 6: Consider the Ruling for Earlier Assessments
If you have pending assessments (AY 2025-26 or earlier) where commission income was questioned, you may file an appeal before ITAT or higher forums, citing this Jodhpur judgment as precedent.
Key Takeaways
- HUF is Competent: The ITAT Jodhpur ruling (November 2026) confirms that HUF can legitimately earn commission income through its Karta or members without legal impediment.
- Section 4(1) & 2(31) Apply: HUF remains a separate taxable entity under Income Tax Act 2025, and commission is taxable business income under Section 14.
- Documentation is Critical: To defend the claim that income belongs to HUF (not Karta personally), maintain invoices, agreements, and bank accounts in HUF name.
- GST Registration Required: HUF earning commission services must register for GST separately if turnover exceeds threshold, and file GST returns in HUF's name.
- Tax Planning Opportunity: This ruling opens tax planning avenues for HUF members, as HUF's tax slab may be more favorable than individual rates, and business deductions reduce taxable income.
Important Note: This ruling applies primarily to ITAT Jodhpur's jurisdiction. However, similar reasoning applies across India, and the principle is sound under Income Tax Act 2025. We recommend documenting your HUF commission income properly and consulting with tax professionals before claiming large commission amounts.
Need expert help with this? EaseValue CAs in Jaipur β WhatsApp 84400 44833
EaseValue