Section 16(2)(c) CGST 2025-26: ITC Reversal Rules & Compliance Guide

What Happened?

Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act continues to create compliance headaches for Indian businesses in AY 2025-26, despite clear statutory language. Recent judicial pronouncements have clarified the scope of ITC reversal and re-availment, yet field-level ambiguities persist in GST administration. The law now stands settled on core principles, but taxpayers face grey areas in execution, especially regarding the timing and conditions for re-claiming reversed credit.

Background & Legal Context

What is Section 16(2)(c)?

Section 16(2)(c) of the CGST Act 2017 mandates that a registered person must reverse Input Tax Credit (ITC) in specific circumstances. The provision states that ITC on goods or services shall be reversed in the proportion that the turnover of supplies made without payment of tax (or at a concessional rate) bears to total turnover.

Core Statutory Language:

• ITC reversal is mandatory when goods/services are used for both taxable and non-taxable supplies
• Reversal is calculated as a proportion of total turnover
• The proportion is determined by: (Non-taxable/Concessional Supply Turnover) ÷ (Total Turnover)
• Once reversed, ITC can be re-claimed only if the proportion of non-taxable supplies in subsequent period decreases

Interaction with Income Tax Act 2025:

While ITC reversal is primarily a GST concept, it impacts taxable income calculation under the Income Tax Act 2025. Reversed credit cannot be claimed as an expense deduction under Section 37 of the IT Act, as it represents a disallowance of input benefits. The credit memo issued during reversal flows through P&L accounting and affects taxable profits for AY 2025-26.

What Does This Mean for You?

For Businesses with Mixed Supplies:

If you operate a business making both taxable (GST-liable) and non-taxable or concessional supplies, you are directly impacted. Examples include:

• Educational institutions providing exempt services but purchasing taxable goods
• Financial services providers mixing taxable and exempt supplies
• Healthcare facilities with both OPD (exempt) and diagnostic services (taxable)
• Real estate developers mixing residential (concessional/nil-rated) with commercial supplies

The Reversal Math:

Let's say your business has:

• Taxable supplies: ₹50 lakhs
• Exempt supplies: ₹50 lakhs
• Total turnover: ₹100 lakhs
• ITC available for reversal: ₹50,000

Reversal proportion = ₹50 lakhs ÷ ₹100 lakhs = 50%

You must reverse 50% of your ITC = ₹25,000

Practical Challenge — Re-availment:

Here lies the complexity. Section 16(2)(c) allows re-availment if the proportion of non-taxable supplies in a later period is lower than in the period of reversal. But the CGST Rules do not clearly define:

• Whether monthly or quarterly proportion is used
• How to handle seasonal variations in supply mix
• Whether a financial year comparison is permissible
• Treatment when a business transitions from mixed supplies to only taxable supplies

Impact on Compliance:

Mishandling Section 16(2)(c) can trigger:

• GST demand with interest under Section 73 of CGST Act
• Penalties up to 10% of tax shortfall under Section 122
• Scrutiny during GST audits (especially for FY 2024-25 and 2025-26 filings)
• Income Tax consequences if reversed credit is wrongly claimed as expense

What Should You Do Now?

Step 1: Audit Your Supply Mix

Review GSTR-1 filings for AY 2025-26 and identify:

• All non-taxable/exempt supplies with HSN/SAC codes
• Concessional rate supplies (if any)
• Monthly/quarterly turnover trends

Step 2: Calculate Reversal Proportion

Using the statutory formula, calculate the exact ITC reversal required for each tax period. Document this in working papers with supporting GSTR-3B filings.

Step 3: Track Re-availment Eligibility

Maintain month-wise and quarter-wise records of the proportion of non-taxable supplies. If the proportion decreases in a subsequent period, document the re-availment claim with a clear audit trail.

Step 4: Amend GSTR-3B if Required

If you made an error in reversal calculation in earlier tax periods, file a revised GSTR-3B within 30 days (where applicable). Pay interest at 18% p.a. for the period of short payment.

Step 5: Coordinate with IT Compliance

When reversed ITC flows through your P&L, ensure your Income Tax Act 2025 compliance reflects the same. Avoid double reversal by claiming it again as a disallowance under Section 37.

Step 6: Maintain Documentation

Keep invoices, supply records, GSTR-1 extracts, and reversal calculations for a minimum of 6 years. The GST audit under Section 35 of CGST Act may seek these records.

Key Takeaways

• Section 16(2)(c) Applies to All Mixed-Supply Businesses: Any registered person with both taxable and non-taxable supplies must calculate and reverse ITC proportionately. There is no exemption size threshold.
• Re-availment is Not Automatic: You cannot claim back reversed ITC unless the proportion of non-taxable supplies genuinely decreases in a later period. Speculative re-availment invites penalties.
• Compliance Risk is High in AY 2025-26: GST audits are now frequent, and Section 16(2)(c) is a common audit trigger. Many businesses fail to document the proportion calculation, leading to demands and interest.
• IT Act Integration Matters: Reversed ITC affects your taxable profit under Income Tax Act 2025. Ensure consistency between GST records and IT filings to avoid double denial of benefits.
• Early Action Required for AY 2025-26: If you have not reviewed your reversal calculations for FY 2024-25 or 2025-26, do so immediately. File revised GST returns before any notice is issued.

Bottom Line: Section 16(2)(c) is settled in principle but demands precision in practice. The burden of proof lies on you to demonstrate correct reversal and re-availment calculations. Non-compliance can be costly.

Need expert help with this? EaseValue CAs in Jaipur — WhatsApp 63677 44602