What Happened?
In November 2026, a significant procedural issue has surfaced regarding Goods and Services Tax composition scheme applications. GST officers have been informally denying composition applications through manual issue of Form CMP-05 (Intimation of Approval for Composition) and Form CMP-07 (Intimation of Rejection for Composition), without these denials being formally recorded on the GST portal. This creates a dangerous grey zone where taxpayers remain unclear about their actual composition status, while simultaneously facing demands related to Input Tax Credit (ITC) on opening stock and retrospective tax demands.
Background & Legal Context
The Goods and Services Tax composition scheme is governed under Section 10 of the CGST Act, 2017, read with Rule 8 of the CGST Rules, 2017. The scheme offers simplified compliance for small traders with an annual turnover up to ₹1.5 crore (or ₹75 lakh in specific states).
- Form CMP-05: Issued by the tax authority to approve a composition application. This form acts as official confirmation of scheme enrollment.
- Form CMP-07: Issued to reject a composition application. This form should formally communicate denial of the scheme benefit.
Under Rule 8(5) of CGST Rules, 2017, the tax authority must pass an order either approving or rejecting the application within 30 days. The critical requirement is that this approval or rejection must be communicated through the GST portal—the official, digitized channel for all GST communications.
However, the current issue reveals that many GST officers are resorting to manual, offline issuance of CMP-07 (and sometimes CMP-05) rejection letters. These manual denials:
- Never appear on the taxpayer's online GST dashboard
- Lack the official portal timestamp and audit trail
- Create ambiguity about the applicant's actual composition status
- Leave no formal record for the taxpayer to challenge or appeal
This practice violates the fundamental principle of transparency and digitalization mandated under the GST regime. More importantly, it creates a legal lacuna where officers can later claim denials were communicated, while taxpayers remain unaware they have been rejected.
What Does This Mean for You?
For Composition Scheme Applicants:
- Portal is the Only Valid Channel: Any denial of composition that does not appear on your GST portal dashboard is not a valid denial. The GST law recognizes portal-based communication as the sole official medium. If an officer claims you were rejected but no CMP-07 appears online, you have grounds to challenge this claim.
- ITC on Opening Stock – A Critical Issue: When a composition application is rejected, one major consequence is the reversal of Input Tax Credit (ITC) on opening stock. Under Rule 8(6) of CGST Rules, 2017, if a composition application is rejected retrospectively, the applicant must reverse ITC claimed on opening inventory. However, if rejection is communicated only manually (and not on portal), does it legally stand? This ambiguity has created disputes. Many taxpayers are now facing demands for ITC reversal on stock, citing manual rejections that cannot be verified online.
- Retrospective Demands – A Dangerous Game: Officers are now issuing retrospective demands for unpaid tax amounts, supposedly dating back to when the composition was allegedly denied (manually). Without a portal record, these demands become difficult to contest. A taxpayer may have operated under the assumption of approved composition, only to later receive surprise demands from officers claiming a manual denial occurred.
- Your Compliance Status is Unclear: If your composition status is not clearly reflected on the portal, you face a double risk: (a) You may inadvertently continue filing composition returns when you should file regular returns, or (b) You may abandon composition benefits when you were actually approved. Either scenario invites penalties.
For Business Planning:
This uncertainty directly impacts your ability to plan tax strategy. The composition scheme offers a 1% or 5% flat tax rate (depending on category) instead of paying GST on every transaction. If your status is unclear, you cannot reliably project your tax liability.
What Should You Do Now?
1. Verify Your Status on Portal: Log into your GST portal (www.gst.gov.in – My Applications section) and check if your composition application shows an approved or rejected status. Cross-check the date of approval/rejection.
2. If You Received a Manual Rejection Letter:
- File a formal RTI (Right to Information) request with the GST authority asking for the official CMP-07 that was supposedly issued to you.
- If no official CMP-07 exists in the system, the rejection is legally questionable.
- Request the authority to formally process and upload any rejection on the portal.
3. Challenge Manual Denials: If an officer claims your composition was denied but no portal record exists, raise a written objection stating that Section 10 and Rule 8 of CGST Rules mandate portal-based communication. Manual communication does not satisfy statutory requirements.
4. File an Appeal Under Rule 112 of CGST Rules: If your composition application was rejected (whether manually or on portal), you have the right to file an appeal before the Appellate Authority within 30 days. Use this route to challenge rejections lacking proper portal documentation.
5. Document Everything: Maintain a file of:
- Your composition application (CMP-01)
- Portal screenshots showing your current status
- Any manual letters received from the officer
- Correspondence requesting clarification
- ITC records on opening stock claimed during the disputed period
6. Immediate Compliance: Until your status is clear on the portal, consider filing composition returns (Form CMP-08) as a precaution. This is safer than assuming rejection without portal proof. If you were rejected, filing composition returns despite rejection can invite penalties, but you have the defense that the rejection was not validly communicated through the portal.
Key Takeaways
- Portal Supremacy: Under GST law, the official portal is the only valid channel for communicating composition approval or rejection. Manual issuance of CMP-05 or CMP-07 without portal upload is procedurally defective.
- Burden on GST Officer: The tax authority must prove that a composition was rejected through valid means. A manual letter alone, without portal record, is insufficient proof under Rule 8(5) CGST Rules.
- ITC Reversal Risk: If officers demand reversal of ITC on opening stock citing a manual rejection, challenge it by requesting the official CMP-07 from the portal. If none exists, the demand is questionable.
- Retrospective Demands Vulnerable: Retrospective tax demands (attempting to tax transactions from a date before manual rejection) can be challenged on the ground that the rejection itself lacks valid portal communication. Build your defense using this argument.
- Seek Formal Clarification: Do not wait passively. Write to the GST authority immediately requesting them to clarify your composition status on the portal. This creates an official record and protects you from future disputes.
The November 2026 scenario highlights a critical gap in GST administration—the distinction between procedurally valid actions and informal ones. The law always favors the taxpayer when the administration acts outside statutory channels. Use this principle to protect yourself.
Need expert help with this? EaseValue CAs in Jaipur — WhatsApp 84400 44833
EaseValue