What Happened?
The Delhi High Court has delivered a landmark judgment on GST treatment of corporate guarantees. The court has upheld the levy of GST on corporate guarantee services but has partially read down the 1% valuation rule that was being applied uniformly across all guarantee transactions. This ruling, delivered in November 2026, clarifies the position for businesses providing or receiving corporate guarantee services and affects how they calculate GST on such services.
Background & Legal Context
Corporate guarantees are financial commitments where one company guarantees the debt or obligation of another. Under the GST regime, guarantee services are classified as financial services attracting 5% GST. However, the valuation of these guarantee services has remained contentious.
The 1% Rule Issue:
- The GST authorities were applying a blanket 1% valuation rule, treating the value of guarantee services as 1% of the guaranteed amount
- This meant if Company A guaranteed a ₹100 crore loan, the guarantee service value was fixed at ₹1 crore, regardless of actual commercial terms
- Businesses argued this was arbitrary and did not reflect the true value of the guarantee service provided
- Under Section 15 of the CGST Act, 2017, the transaction value should be the price actually paid or payable for the supply
What the Court Ruled:
- GST on corporate guarantee services remains applicable—this is now settled law
- The fixed 1% valuation rule is not mandatory in all cases
- Actual consideration charged between parties (if documented and commercially justified) should be accepted
- The court observed that the value should be determined based on the nature of risk, duration of guarantee, and commercial terms
- However, the ruling does not eliminate GST on guarantees—it only relaxes the mechanical 1% application
Applicable Legal Sections:
- Section 15 of CGST Act, 2017 – Determination of transaction value
- Schedule III of CGST Act – Guarantee services classified as financial services
- Notification 12/2017-CT (Rate) – 5% GST on financial services
- Corresponding provisions in IGST Act, 2017 for inter-state transactions
What Does This Mean for You?
For Businesses Providing Guarantee Services (Banks, NBFCs, Guarantee Companies):
- Positive Impact: You now have flexibility in valuing guarantee services. If you have charged a fee higher than 1% of the guarantee amount based on commercial negotiation, you can defend this valuation with proper documentation
- Documentation is Critical: You must maintain records showing how the guarantee fee was determined—risk assessment, duration, market comparables, credit rating of the guarantor, etc.
- GST Still Applies: Do not misinterpret this as elimination of GST. At 5% rate, GST is still payable on the actual value determined. You will pay GST on the fee charged, not on the guaranteed amount
- Invoicing: Issue invoices showing the guarantee service value clearly, with GST separately charged at 5%
- ITC Position: If you are a service provider receiving input services, you can claim ITC on GST paid on inputs used for providing guarantee services
For Businesses Receiving/Availing Guarantee Services (Borrowers, Corporates):
- Lower GST Cost: If the guarantee service value is less than 1% (commercial negotiation), your total cost reduces
- ITC Claim: The GST paid on guarantee services may be eligible for input tax credit if you are in a GST-taxable business (subject to apportionment rules)
- Documentation: Ensure the guarantee agreement and invoicing clearly specify the fee charged. Vague or undisclosed arrangements may face scrutiny
- Assessment Year 2025-26 and 2026-27: Businesses can revisit past guarantee transactions (within limitation period) if they had been charged 1% mechanically despite lower commercial value
For Finance and Treasury Departments:
- Review all corporate guarantee transactions entered into during AY 2025-26 and AY 2026-27
- Identify cases where 1% was applied but actual fee was different
- Consider filing revised returns if the guarantee value charged was significantly different and GST was overpaid
- Update GST valuation policies and procedures to reflect this judgment
What Should You Do Now?
Immediate Steps:
- Review Past Transactions: Identify all corporate guarantee transactions in the last 3-5 years where you may have applied the 1% rule mechanically
- Assess Commercial Value: Determine what the actual commercial value of each guarantee should have been based on risk, tenor, and market practice
- Document Evidence: Collect supporting documents—guarantee agreements, risk assessments, comparable market rates, credit ratings, correspondence with the guaranteed party about fee negotiation
- Consult Your CA: Engage a GST specialist to evaluate if any past overpayment or underpayment of GST occurred and whether revised returns should be filed
- Update Processes: Going forward, ensure guarantee service valuations are done on a case-by-case basis with proper commercial justification
For Future Guarantee Transactions:
- Negotiate and document the guarantee fee explicitly in the guarantee agreement
- Base the fee on commercial parameters: nature of obligor, tenor of guarantee, extent of risk, guarantor's credit rating, and market comparables
- Issue GST invoices showing this agreed fee (not a mechanical 1%)
- Maintain a file containing the valuation rationale for audit defense
- If disputes arise, this judgment gives you legal backing to challenge mechanical 1% application
For Revised Return Filing:
- If GST was overpaid in earlier years, Form GSTR-1 amended returns can be filed within the prescribed period
- Refund claims should be supported by detailed documentation and commercial justification for the revised value
- CBIC or state GST authorities may issue further guidance; monitor official notifications
Key Takeaways
- GST on corporate guarantees remains mandatory at 5% rate—this judgment does not exempt guarantees from GST
- The 1% mechanical valuation rule is not legally binding—actual value charged between parties should be accepted if commercially justified and documented
- Proper documentation of guarantee fee calculation is now critical—simply invoicing 1% without backing may invite GST officer scrutiny
- Businesses can revisit past transactions and potentially claim refunds if they overpaid GST by applying 1% when actual value was lower
- This judgment applies to corporate guarantees going forward in AY 2026-27 onwards and potentially to pending assessments for earlier years
Final Note: While this Delhi HC judgment is favorable in clarifying that the 1% rule is not universal, GST still applies on guarantee services. The burden of proof remains on the guarantee provider to demonstrate that the charged value is commercially justified. Weak documentation will not protect you—invest in proper valuation support and record-keeping.
Need expert help with this? EaseValue CAs in Jaipur — WhatsApp 84400 44833
EaseValue